Friday May 11 -
Death
Row Cases Come With Twists
By
CALVIN WOODWARD, WASHINGTON - Throughout history and
especially now, death-row cases have come with wrenching twists in
the last weeks, days, hours, minutes. Even last meals don't mean
it's over.The postponement Friday of Timothy McVeigh (news - web
sites)'s execution date was extraordinary in that it was motivated
not by the condemned man, who seems detached about his fate, but
by the government on the basis of a blunder.Yet 11th-hour detours
from the death chamber are practically commonplace in the annals
of American capital punishment, for the infamous and the
unknown.``Spies Get 1 More Day,'' screamed the headline in a
tabloid clutched by the bewildered children of Julius and Ethel
Rosenberg in June 1953, before their parents were put to death for
giving atomic-bomb secrets to the Soviets.In a modern-day case
that contributed to the moratorium on Illinois executions, Anthony
Porter had ordered his last meal and been fitted for burial
clothes before winning a temporary reprieve in 1998.Then another
man confessed to the murder, clearing him.``The death penalty is a
roller coaster in terms of dates,'' said Richard C. Dieter,
director of the Death Penalty Information Center.``Typically
people have two or three or four execution dates before it's
carried out - if it's carried out.''The Rosenbergs' trial was a
sensation; many protested its fairness and Albert Einstein and the
pope asked that the couple be spared.The couple lived an extra day
when the case was referred to the Supreme Court, which refused to
hear appeals. The children, then 6 and 10, were photographed
looking at the paper that chronicled their parents' last
hope.McVeigh, convicted of killing 168 people in the 1995 Oklahoma
City bombing, was scheduled to be put to death Wednesday in the
first federal execution since 1963. The government ordered a
30-day stay after the FBI (news - web sites) said it found
documents it had failed to turned over to McVeigh's
defense.Officials said the documents do not contain anything that
clouds the jury's verdict or McVeigh's admission of
responsibility.Still, Bush, overseeing his first execution stay as
president, said the postponement ``is an example of the system
being fair.''Last year, Bush authorized the only 30-day stay he
granted as Texas governor, in the case of Ricky Nolen
McGinn.McGinn was only 18 minutes from death and had eaten what
was supposed to have been his last meal when Bush put off the
execution so new DNA evidence could be considered. McGinn, a
convicted child killer, was executed in September after the
evidence failed to exonerate him.In normal circumstances, Dieter
noted, most condemned prisoners never are put to death. Only about
10 percent of the 7,000 death penalty sentences ordered since
capital punishment was reinstated in 1976 have been carried
out.Those executed in 1999 spent an average of 11 years and 11
months on death row, a government study has found.McVeigh decided
earlier to drop all appeals, but as his lawyers pored over the
withheld documents, they indicated he could decide to pursue
avenues available to him.Public demands to save the lives of the
condemned have animated other famous cases, including that of
Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, anarchists executed in 1927
for robbery and murder six years after a trial considered unfair
by many then and now.No such movement has sprung up for McVeigh.The
last prisoner executed by the federal government tried until the
end to save himself.President Kennedy was pulled from the White
House swimming pool to take a call asking him to look into the
case of Victor Feguer, convicted of killing an Iowa doctor after
driving him across state lines.Kennedy ultimately denied clemency;
Feguer was hanged after a last meal consisting of a single olive
with the pit still in it.Last year, President Clinton (news - web
sites) twice delayed the federal execution of Juan Raul Garza,
each time within a week of the scheduled date. The Texan is
scheduled to be executed June 19.Such down-to-the-wire attention
came too late for Leon Jerome Moser in Pennsylvania, convicted
killer of his ex-wife and two daughters, in 1995.Nine minutes
after lethal drugs began coursing into Moser, a judge placed a
final call hoping to get him on the phone to gauge his competency.
|