Richmond
Times-Dispatch -
12/11/01)
Virginia
Commission Finds Death Penalty Applied Inconsistently
A
study released by the Joint Legislative Audit Review Commission found that
the death penalty in Virginia is applied more often in rural and suburban
jurisdictions than in urban ones, even when the underlying crimes are
similar. The study, which examined 160 of the 215 capital punishment
eligible cases from 1995-1999, found that the death penalty was sought 45%
of the time in suburban districts, 34% of the time in rural districts, and
only 16% of the time in urban areas. "Can the disparate outcomes
which flow from the proper exercise of prosecutorial discretion be
accepted in a system where the ultimate sanction is execution?" asked
the Commission. In addition, the study suggested that the Virginia Supreme
Court was too narrow in deciding whether a death sentence was excessive or
disproportionate. The Court has never found a case of excessive sentencing
in the 119 cases that have come before it since 1977.
|