February 1, 2002
Illinois to Reform Death Penalty
CHICAGO
- The Illinois Death Penalty Commission, created two years ago when Gov. George Ryan declared a
moratorium on executions, has agreed to recommend
dozens of changes to the state's capital punishment system.
The 14-member panel at one point voted to abolish
capital punishment in the state, several commission members
told the Chicago Tribune for its Friday
editions.
``We took the governor at his word when he said, 'I
want you to review this process and say how it can be
fair,''' Cook County Public Defender Rita Fry said. ``We came
up with ways how it can be fairer. ... But that doesn't
mean it can actually be fair.''
Commission members refused to comment to The
Associated Press before a closed-door meeting
Friday.
The governor declared a moratorium after Illinois saw
13 people freed from death row amid new evidence of
innocence or improper prosecution. The state has executed 12
people since reinstating the death penalty in 1977.
A draft report from the panel says executions should
not resume if the panel's reforms are not enacted, the
Chicago Sun-Times reported, citing an anonymous source
familiar with the commission's work.
But at least one panel member expressed doubts that
the final report will include a recommendation to abolish
the death penalty.
``I do not expect it will contain anything about
abolition. I just don't see it as our role,'' Frank McGarr, a
retired federal judge and one of three panel chairmen, told
the Daily Herald of Arlington Heights.
Commission members refused to discuss specific reforms
that they were considering recommending. In
November, the independent Illinois Death Penalty Education Project
recommended 12 proposals that would require the
videotaping of confessions, separating the state crime lab from
the state police and studying whether the death penalty is
unfairly applied to minorities. It also said that
anyone convicted based on the testimony of a single
eyewitness should be ineligible for capital
punishment.
The commission's final report will be sent to the
governor.
``Once I get the report, I won't be able to walk out
and say, 'I got it, and here's what we're going to do,'''
Ryan said. ``I'm going to have to study it and look at it
and ask some questions and do a little research of my
own.''
While some death penalty reforms have stalled in the
Illinois General Assembly, the state Supreme Court has
set minimum standards for death penalty lawyers and in
March will start to screen lawyers for admission to a new
Capital Litigation Trial Bar.
|