|
Maryland
annuncia moratoria
Maryland
Declares Death Penalty Moratorium
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The Toronto star
|
|
PENA DI MORTE: MARYLAND ANNUNCIA MORATORIA
WASHINGTON, 9 MAG - Il governatore del
Maryland Parris Glendening ha annunciato oggi una moratoria
sulle esecuzioni nello Stato finche' non sara' stato
completato uno studio per accertare che non vi sia stata
discriminazione razziale nell'uso della pena capitale. (ANSA).
Nei bracci della morte delle
carceri del Maryland si trovano tredici detenuti:
nove di questi
sono neri.
L'esecuzione
di Wesley Eugene Baker era in programma la prossima settimana. E' stata sospesa, come lo
saranno tutte le successive finche' un ricercatore dell'Universita'
del Maryland non avra' completato uno studio sulla equita'
razziale delle sentenze di morte nello stato.
Lo
studio dovrebbe essere completato entro settembre. Fino ad allora la moratoria restera' in vigore in Maryland.
Nel
2000 il governatore dell'Illinois George Ryan e' stato il primo a decretare una moratoria sulla
pena di morte nel suo stato per esaminare metodi di riforma giudiziaria
che possono
ridurre la possibilita' di sentenze di morte per
detenuti innocenti.
09-MAG-02 18:23
MARYLAND DICHIARA MORATORIA
MA IN ALABAMA DOMANI UNA DONNA MORIRA' SU SEDIA
ELETTRICA
WASHINGTON, 9 MAG - Il Maryland e' diventato oggi il
secondo Stato americano a dichiarare una moratoria
sulla pena di morte. Un'analoga decisione era stata annunciata
nel 2000 dall' Illinois.
Il
governatore del Maryland Parris Glendening ha spiegato di aver deciso la moratoria per i dubbi esistenti
''nel nostro Stato e nel resto del paese su una applicazione
imparziale della
pena
di morte''.
La
moratoria restera' in vigore finche' non sara' stato completato uno studio di uno specialista
dell'Universita'
del Maryland (che dovrebbe essere pronto a settembre)
sulla equita' di applicazione delle condanne capitali,
soprattutto sotto il profilo della discriminazione razziale.
Nei
bracci della morte del Maryland sono in attesa 13 condannati: nove sono di colore.
La
decisione del governatore ha sospeso l'esecuzione del nero Wesley Eugene
Baker, in programma la prossima
settimana.
Glendening
ha detto che nel Maryland non vi saranno esecuzioni finche' la moratoria restera' in vigore.
Il
governatore ha previsto che la moratoria possa restare in vigore almeno un anno, finche' il Congresso avra'
avuto il tempo di studiare e discutere il rapporto dell'Universita'.
Glendening
ha detto di essere favorevole alla pena di morte, specie per i crimini piu' atroci, ma che ''e'
imperativo per tutti avere la certezza che l'iter giudiziario che
precede le condanne capitali sia equo ed imparziale''.
Il
governatore, che sta per completare due mandati, non puo' ripresentarsi una terza volta ed a novembre sara'
nominato il suo successore. La sua vice Kathleen Kennedy
Townsend e' in lizza per la poltrona di Glendening.
Intanto
in Alabama sara' messa a morte sulla sedia elettrica, nei primi minuti di domani, Lynda Lyon Block, 53
anni, accusata di aver ucciso un poliziotto nel 1993.
Sara'
la prima donna a morire per mano del boia in Alabama dal 1957, se non vi sara' un rinvio all'ultimo
momento della esecuzione. Sara' inoltre la nona donna ad essere
messa a morte negli Stati Uniti da quando nel 1976 sono riprese
le esecuzioni
nel paese.
Lynda
Block sara' anche l'ultima persona a morire sulla sedia elettrica in Alabama: dal primo luglio lo stato
adottera' il metodo della iniezione.
Al
momento, oltre 3.700 persone sono rinchiuse nei bracci della morte dei 38 Stati Usa che continuano ad
effettuare esecuzioni.
Il
sistema giudiziario � razzista?
MARYLAND
(CNN) -- Il governatore del Maryland, Parris Glendening, ha imposto una
moratoria sulla pena di morte finch� non sar� completato uno studio
che determiner� se le condanne a morte sono imposte in questo stato in
base a criteri razziali.
Dei
13 detenuti che si trovano attualmente nei bracci della morte delle
prigioni del Maryland, nove sono neri.
Tra
questi, Wesley Eugene Baker, la cui esecuzione programmata per la
prossima settimana � stata per il momento sospesa.
E'
fondamentale, ha detto Glendening, che i cittadini abbiano piena fiducia
nel processo legale riguardante la pena di morte e che questo sia giusti
e imparziali. Il governatore ha spiegato che la ricerca, cominciata nel
2000 e condotta dall'Universit� del Maryland, sar� completata alla
fine di quest'anno.
Nel
2000 il governatore dell'Illinois, George Ryan, era stato il primo a
decretare una moratoria sulla pena di morte nel suo stato per esaminare
metodi di riforma giudiziaria che possono ridurre la possibilit� di
sentenze di morte per detenuti innocenti.
Maryland
Declares Death Penalty Moratorium
May 9, 2002
By
Bryan Sears
ANNAPOLIS,
Md. - Maryland on Thursday became the second U.S. state to
declare a moratorium on executions, citing "reasonable
questions" about the integrity of capital punishment within its own
boundaries and across the nation.
Gov.
Parris Glendening announced he would stay all executions until the
University of Maryland completes an intensive study of 6,000 homicide
cases to determine whether the state system for imposing the death
penalty is fraught with racial and geographic bias.
"Reasonable
questions have been raised in Maryland and across the country about the
application of the death penalty," said Glendening, noting that
recent studies have produced evidence pointing to racial bias in capital
murder cases in largely white and suburban Baltimore County.
"There
is a logical inconsistency to say we're reviewing the fairness and
justice of the death penalty process, and in the meantime, we're going
to execute," he told a news conference.
The
study, initiated in 2000 at the urging of black state legislators, is
due to be completed in September.
Maryland
has executed three inmates since the state's death penalty was
reinstated in 1978. The latest was in 1998. State officials said the
governor's action on Thursday prevented as many as five death-row
inmates from facing execution by lethal injection over the next four
months.
Nine
of Maryland's 13 death-row inmates are black, and all but one of those
were convicted of murdering whites in predominantly white communities.
One black inmate, Wesley Eugene Baker, was due to die next week for
murdering a woman in front of her grandchildren during a shopping mall
robbery in 1991.
EXECUTION
OPPONENTS HAIL MOVE
Death-penalty
opponents hailed the Maryland moratorium as an important victory, saying
it should be followed by sweeping reforms like those recently proposed
in Illinois where Republican Gov. George Ryan imposed the first state
moratorium in January 2000 after several death-row inmates were found to
be innocent.
According
to Amnesty International, 100 people have been exonerated from death row
in the United States since 1973.
"The
administration of the death penalty is a deeply troubled government
program and governors who look at these problems, and who are honest see, that they have to do
something," said George Kendall, staff
attorney for the NAACP Legal Defense Fund.
"Maryland
has a real problem with race," he added.
Criminal
justice officials in the United States have been criticized by
death-penalty opponents around the world for maintaining capital
punishment at both the state and federal levels.
Thirty-eight
states have death penalty laws on their books. Last year, there were
3,711 prisoners on death row in the United States, according to the
NAACP Legal Defense Fund. Since 1976, 773 people have been executed.
Amnesty
International says the United States is one of 84 nations where the
death penalty is exercised, compared with 111 in which it has been
abolished in some form. Western Europe has abolished the practice and
Russia has commuted the sentences of all of its death-row inmates to
life in prison, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.
In
the United States, recent opinion polls have shown growing support for
life-without-parole as an alternative to death.
"We
are now at a point in the debate on capital punishment in America where
the country recognizes that if it were to have capital punishment, then
you have to be serious about reforms," said law expert Barry Scheck, co-director of the New York-based Innocence
Project, which has
used post-conviction DNA testing to overturn 60 criminal cases in recent
years.
"This
is not just a Maryland issue," said Democratic U.S. Sen. Russ
Feingold of Wisconsin, author of a bill to impose a moratorium on
federal executions. "Problems of troubling racial disparities and
the risk of executing the innocent plague the administration of the
death penalty nationwide."
LEGISLATURE
DEFEATED MORATORIUM
Glendening,
a two-term Democratic governor who must leave office in January because
of term limits, commuted the sentence of a death-row inmate to life two
years ago because he doubted the strength of the evidence.
The
Maryland Legislature also debated moratorium legislation a year ago. But
the measure was defeated.
Glendening's
moratorium declaration on Thursday came a day after Baker formally
petitioned the governor's office for clemency. The 44-year-old inmate
had his final appeal denied by the U.S. Supreme Court (news - web sites)
earlier this week.
Baker's
lawyers had asked the governor either to commute his death sentence to
life without parole, or to delay his execution until after the release
of the University of Maryland study. They argued that Baker had a
troubled childhood after being born to a 13-year-old girl whose
boyfriend was a violent ex-convict and heroin user.
Maryland's
Gov. Glendening issues death penalty moratorium until study is completed
May 9, 2002
By
TOM STUCKEY
ANNAPOLIS,
Maryland - Gov. Parris Glendening imposed a moratorium Thursday on
executions in Maryland until the state completes a study of whether
there is racial bias in the use of the death penalty.
Only
one other state that has capital punishment, Illinois, has imposed a
similar moratorium.
Glendening,
a Democrat who is barred from seeking a third term this November, issued
a stay on the execution of Wesley Eugene Baker and said he would stay
any other executions that come before him. Baker, 44, had been scheduled
to die by injection sometime next week.
In
announcing his decision, the governor repeated his support for the death
penalty in especially heinous crimes, but said that "reasonable
questions have been raised in Maryland and across the country about the
application of the death penalty."
"It
is imperative that I, as well as our citizens, have complete confidence
that the legal process involved in capital cases is fair and impartial," the governor
said.
Glendening
had been under pressure to halt executions until he receives a study
that is due to be completed in September by a researcher at the
University of Maryland.
Baker
is one of 13 men awaiting execution in Maryland, and critics say the
death penalty is more likely to be imposed if the defendants are black
and the victims are white. Nine of the 13, including Baker, are black,
and many of the victims were white, including the woman Baker was
convicted of killing.
Glendening
said he would not lift the moratorium until the study is completed and
reviewed by the state legislature. He said he expects the moratorium
will remain in place for about a year, unless the next governor resumes
executions after taking office in January.
Lt.
Gov. Kathleen Kennedy Townsend, who also supports the death penalty in
limited cases, had asked Glendening last week to impose the moratorium.
She recently announced she is running to succeed him.
Illinois
Gov. George Ryan declared the U.S.'s first moratorium in 2000, citing
the release of 13 death-row inmates whose convictions were flawed. Last
month, a commission appointed by Ryan recommended reforms to reduce the
possibility of wrongful convictions, including cutting the number of
crimes eligible for the death penalty and videotaping police
interrogations.
About
3,700 people are on death row for crimes committed in the 38 states that
allow the death penalty.
Since
the U.S. Supreme Court (news - web sites) reinstated the death penalty
25 years ago, more than 770 inmates have been put to death in the United
States by the federal government and authorities in 32 states.
Baker
was sentenced to die by lethal injection for the 1991 murder of Jane
Tyson, 49, who was shot in the parking lot of a Baltimore County
shopping center, where she had taken her 4-year-old granddaughter and
6-year-old grandson shopping for tennis shoes.
Baker
does not deny taking part in an attempted robbery when Tyson was killed,
but his attorneys say there is not enough evidence to show he fired the
gun. Gregory Lawrence, a co-defendant, was sentenced to life in prison.
Baker's
lawyer, Gary Christopher, had filed two petitions with Glendening on
Tuesday, one asking that Baker's sentence be reduced to life in prison
and one asking for a stay while the university study is completed.
Glendening
has allowed two men to die by lethal injection, but commuted the
sentence of a third, Eugene Colvin-el, to life without parole a week
before his scheduled execution two years ago. Glendening said then that
he was not absolutely certain that Colvin-el was guilty of the murder
for which he was sentenced to death.
9 mai 2002,
Peine de mort: le gouverneur du Maryland d�cr�te
un moratoire sur les ex�cutions
ANNAPOLIS, Maryland - Le gouverneur Parris
Glendening a d�cr�t� jeudi un moratoire sur les ex�cutions dans le
Maryland le temps que cet Etat am�ricain ach�ve une �tude sur la
peine capitale.
Ce travail doit d�terminer si les pr�jug�s
raciaux influent sur le recours � la peine de mort.
Le gouverneur du Maryland a accord� un sursis �
Wesley Eugene Baker, qui devait �tre ex�cut� par injection l�tale la
semaine prochaine. Il a indiqu� qu'il ferait de m�me pour toutes les
autres ex�cutions qu'il serait amen� � examiner.
Wesley Eugene Baker figure parmi les 13 hommes,
dont neuf noirs, d�tenus dans les couloirs de la mort au Maryland.
Glendening
Declares Moratorium on Executions
By
Lori Montgomery
Thursday,
May 9, 2002
Maryland
Gov. Parris N. Glendening today declared a moratorium on executions,
sparing the life of a Baltimore-area killer and making Maryland the
second state after Illinois to suspend the death penalty because of
doubts about its fairness.
Glendening
(D) announced his decision after reviewing a clemency request by Wesley
Eugene Baker, 44, who had been scheduled to die next week for murdering
a woman in front of her grandchildren during a purse-snatching in 1991.
Glendening
said he did not come to a conclusion about the soundness of Baker's
conviction. But he said he was troubled that Baker is the first of five
men � four of them black � who could face execution before the end
of Glendening's term as governor.
Glendening
said he decided that those executions should not proceed until a study
examining the state's system of capital punishment for evidence of
racial bias is complete.
"In
effect, I am issuing a moratorium until the study has been released and
reviewed by the governor, reviewed by the public and reviewed by the
legislature," he said.
Glendening
added that he anticipated the moratorium would last for about one year.
"This
is a difficult decision. My heart goes out to the families of the
victims of these horrible crimes," Glendening said. "I must,
however, be absolutely certain not only of the guilt of the criminals
but of the fairness and impartiality of the process."
The
decision marks a change of heart for Glendening, who in the past
rejected calls for a moratorium. At that time, the governor said he saw
no need to issue a blanket stay because he personally reviewed the case
of each death row inmate for evidence of racial bias before allowing
execution to proceed.
In
recent months, however, Glendening said questions about the fairness of
the death penalty have mounted across the nation. Last month, an
Illinois commission recommended sweeping reform of capital punishment in
Illinois. And in Arizona, the 100th person in the nation was freed from
death row after being exonerated by DNA evidence.
In
Maryland, nine of 13 men on death row come from a single jurisdiction:
Baltimore County. Seventy percent of the men are black, one of the
highest proportions on any death row. And all but one of the men were
condemned for killing white victims, although 80 percent of the state's
murder victims are black.
With
the study of racial bias due in September � and with Baker's execution
looming � African-American leaders, Catholic church officials and
other death-penalty opponents stepped up their calls on Glendening to
declare a moratorium.
Glendening
said he ultimately decided it would be "logically
inconsistent" to put as many as five men to death while the study
is underway.
Glendening
said he still believes strongly in the right of society to impose the
"ultimate sanction" on crimes that "shock the
conscience."
But,
he said, "a maximum of one more year delay to make absolutely
certain for me, or any future governor, that the process is fair is a
reasonable thing to do."
For Convicted Killer, A Chance at Life
By Peter Carlson
Friday, May 10,
2002
Last
week, guards took convicted killer Wesley
Eugene Baker out of his cell in Maryland's supermax prison in Baltimore
and escorted him to an isolation area to await his execution, scheduled
for next week.
Last night -- after Maryland
Gov. Parris N.
Glendening declared a moratorium on executions in the state -- the
guards moved Baker, 44, back to his old cell. Now he doesn't have to
worry about being killed by lethal injection -- at least not until next
year, after legislators review a study on racial bias in murder
convictions. Four of the five men awaiting execution in the next few
months are blacks convicted of murdering whites.
"He was very moved by what the governor did
today," says Baker's lawyer, Gary Christopher, who visited his
client after Glendening's announcement. "He feels very humbled by
what happened. He understands the ramifications of this for the future
of the death penalty in Maryland, and that sort of overwhelms him."
Baker's road to death row began in the parking
lot of Westview Mall outside Baltimore on June 6, 1991.
At 8:30 that
evening, Jane Tyson was climbing
into the driver's seat of her Buick, after buying shoes for her
grandchildren -- Adam Sulewski, 6, and Carly Sulewski, 4 -- when a man
ran up to her, shot her in the head and ran off with her purse, leaving
her lying on the pavement, bleeding from the head and mouth.
The shooter and another man fled in a blue Chevy
Blazer. When police caught up with the Blazer a few minutes later, Baker
bailed out of the passenger seat and ran. After police nabbed him, they
discovered traces of Tyson's blood on his shoe, sock and pants.
He was charged with murder. The driver of the
Blazer, Gregory Lawrence, was charged as an accomplice.
The two men were tried
separately. At his trial,
Lawrence testified that Baker shot Tyson. He was convicted and sentenced
to life. At his trial, Baker declined to testify. He was convicted and
sentenced to death.
For a decade, Baker has waited on death row as
lawyers fought to save his life. Last month, after prison officials
scheduled Baker's execution, his lawyers petitioned Glendening for
clemency, arguing that doubt remains about whether Baker fired the shot
that killed Tyson.
Ann
Brobst, who prosecuted Baker, says she has
no doubt that Baker was the shooter. Tyson's "blood was on his sock
and pants," she says. She does wonder why he shot the unarmed
woman. "I don't know why he killed her," she says. "She
was vulnerable. She was a very small woman, and she was with two very
small children. I suspect it was because he wasn't masked, and he didn't
want to leave a witness."
In their clemency
petition, Baker's lawyers
argued that his crime was mitigated by a horrific childhood. He was born
in 1958, the son of an unmarried 14-year-old Baltimore girl.
"Prior to age
five, Mr. Baker was abducted
and sexually abused by two teenage girls," Christopher and another
lawyer, William Purpura, wrote. "His stepfather physically abused
Mrs. Baker and forced a young Wesley to watch him inject heroin
intravenously. Mr. Baker's drug and alcohol abuse began at the age of
ten and by age fourteen, he had graduated to intravenous heroin use. At
age fifteen, he fathered a child with a 28-year-old intravenous heroin
abuser . . . "
"We
don't offer that as an excuse, but as
an explanation," says Christopher. "We start with the
proposition that he'll be imprisoned for life."
Glendening did not rule on
Baker's clemency
petition yesterday. Instead, he declared a moratorium on all executions
until the state legislature can review a study, currently in the works,
of possible racial bias in Maryland's system of capital punishment.
The legislature is not scheduled to meet until
January. By then, Glendening will be out of office. His successor will
have to decide Baker's fate.
Yesterday, Christopher marveled at how calm
Baker had been as he faced imminent execution. "I'm very proud of
how he was managing to weather the process. I don't know anybody else
who has ever been told, 'You will be dead within a week at the hands of
the state.' He was supporting me as much as I was supporting him. He was
helping his family to get through the process. It wasn't like he was
whining or upset with what was coming his way."
Baker's
mother, Delores Williams, visited her
son yesterday and then released a statement to the media: "I'm so
appreciative of what everyone did. I'm grateful to Governor Glendening
for staying my son's execution from the bottom of my heart."
Reached by
phone, John Tyson, the husband of Baker's victim, declined to comment on
Glendening's action. "I don't have anything to say," he
whispered. Then he gently hung up the phone.
Maryland's governor issues death penalty
moratorium
Maryland
Gov. Glendening said he will not lift
the moratorium on the death penalty until the state legislature reviews
a study.
May 9, 2002
ANNAPOLIS, Maryland (CNN) -- Maryland Gov.
Parris Glendening imposed a moratorium on executions Thursday until the
state finishes a study on whether there is racial bias in the use of the
death penalty.
Glendening, a Democrat, said he envisions the
stay remaining in place "until the study is reviewed and acted upon
by the legislature, which I expect to take about one year."
Glendening stopped the execution of Wesley
Eugene Baker, who was scheduled to die by lethal injection some time
next week, and said he would stay any other executions that come before
him. Baker was convicted of a 1991 murder.
Nine of the 13 people on death row in Maryland
are African-American, including Baker. During his tenure, Glendening
allowed the state to go forward with two executions, but he commuted a
third. The Baker case was the fourth such case to come before him.
"It is imperative that I, as well as our
citizens, have complete confidence that the legal process involved in
capital cases is fair and impartial," Glendening said.
"An extensive two-year study by the
University of Maryland examining the effects of racial and
jurisdictional factors on the imposition of the death penalty is nearing
completion."
The university study was commissioned in the
spring of 2000 and is expected to be completed later this year.
"Given that the study will be released soon,
and the critical need to be absolutely sure of the integrity of the
process, I am issuing a stay for this case, and I will stay any others
that come before me, pending completion of the study," the governor
said.
Glendening has said the death penalty is not a
deterrent to crime, but believes that there are some crimes so vicious
that society has the right to impose the harshest of all punishments,
said Karen White, the governor's spokeswoman.
Glendening said the decision to halt executions
was a "difficult" one that was not "based on the
specifics of these cases."
"While I have not conducted a full and
comprehensive review of each case, I do know that the crimes for which
the death row inmates were convicted and sentenced were vicious. They
are precisely the type of terrible murders that call for the ultimate
sanction," he said.
Glendening, whose second and final term of
office ends in January, said the next governor "will have the
authority to adjust the timetable" on the moratorium.
Lt.
Gov. Kathleen Kennedy Townsend, a Democratic
candidate for governor, called for a death penalty moratorium last week
and met with Glendening on the issue, although she did not discuss
Baker's case or other individual cases, according to a Townsend campaign
spokeswoman.
"Kathleen Kennedy Townsend supports the
death penalty but believes if you are going to impose the death penalty
you must be sure it is as fair as possible," the spokeswoman said.
"We support this moratorium because it
gives us an opportunity to clarify that we are being as fair and just as
we can be and we must be."
Illinois
Gov. George Ryan declared the nation's
first moratorium in 2000. The Associated Press reported that last month,
a commission appointed by Ryan recommended 85 reforms to reduce the
possibility of wrongful convictions. Some of the reforms included
cutting the number of crimes eligible for the death penalty and
videotaping police interrogations.
US governor freezes executions
Lethal injection is the most common method of
execution
The governor of Maryland in the United States
has imposed a moratorium on the death penalty until a report into
whether there is racial bias in executions is completed.
Thursday, 9
May, 2002,
Death penalty USA
38 states have the death penalty
More then 3,700 inmates are on death row
Execution can be by hanging, electrocution,
gassing, firing squad or lethal injection
Four states still use the electric chair
The
governor, Parris Glendening, issued a stay
on the execution of Wesley Baker, an African American, and all other
pending executions in the state citing "reasonable questions"
about the integrity of capital punishment in the state and across the
country.
Baker is one of 13 men - nine of them black -
awaiting execution in Maryland.
The study - financed with the support of
legislature - is being carried out by a researcher at the University of
Maryland, and is due to be completed in autumn next year.
Under pressure
Mr Glendening - a supporter of death penalty for
especially heinous crimes - requested the study two years ago, after
apparently studying Maryland's statistics of inmates on a death row.
Execution factfile
1999 - 97 executions
1951 - 105 executions
95 people released from death row since 1973
66% of Americans support the death penalty
80% take place in southern states
Opponents of the death penalty argue that
executions are imposed on racial minorities in disproportionately high
numbers.
Stephanie Gibson, member of the Maryland
Coalition Against State Executions says that the statistics show that
the majority of those on death row have killed a white person, even
though an overwhelming 80% of the state's homicide victims are coloured
people.
Mr Glendening said he would not lift the
moratorium until the study is reviewed by the state legislature, which
he expected would be completed in about a year's time.
Parole demands
Wesley Baker, 44, was sentenced to die by lethal
injection for the murder of Jane Tyson, who was shot in a Baltimore
County shopping centre in 1991.
Baker does not deny being present when the
victim was killed, but his attorneys say there is not enough evidence to
show he fired the gun.
They demand that the governor either to commute
his death sentence to life without parole, or to delay his execution
until after the release of the study.
Several hundred people have been put to death in
the US by state and federal authorities since the country's Supreme
Court reinstated the death penalty in the late 1970's.
Illinois is the only other US state which has
imposed a moratorium on death penalty.
The Toronto star
Maryland suspends executions
Governor will wait for study of racial bias in
death penalty
ANNAPOLIS, Md. - Following the example set by Illinois
two years ago, Gov. Parris Glendening on Thursday suspended all
executions in Maryland while a study is done on whether the death
penalty is meted out in a racially discriminatory way.
Glendening, a Democrat who is barred from
seeking a third term this fall, blocked next week's lethal injection of
44-year-old Wesley Baker and said he would stay any other executions
that come before him in his eight months left in office.
The governor repeated his support for the death
penalty for especially heinous crimes, but said "reasonable
questions have been raised in Maryland and across the country about the
application of the death penalty.''
"It is imperative that I, as well as our
citizens, have complete confidence that the legal process involved in
capital cases is fair and impartial," he said.
Illinois is the only other death penalty state
to impose a moratorium on executions.
The study is expected to be completed in
September and will then be reviewed by state lawmakers. Glendening said
he expects the moratorium to remain in place for about a year. However,
the next governor is free to resume executions upon taking office in
January.
Nine of the 13 men on Maryland's death row are
black and many of the victims were white. Glendening also noted that
nine of the men on death row were convicted in suburban Baltimore
County, and said: "Use of the death penalty ought not to be a
lottery of geography.''
The
governor's office said five men, including
Baker, could have faced execution before Glendening's term ends.
Democratic Lt. Gov. Kathleen Kennedy Townsend,
who is running for governor and supports the death penalty in some
cases, had asked Glendening to impose the moratorium. The governor said
Townsend's request was not a significant factor in his decision.
About 3,700 people are on death row for crimes
committed in the 38 states with the death penalty. Critics contend the
death penalty is more likely to be imposed if the defendant is black and
the victim white.
Baker, who is black, was convicted of killing a
49-year-old white grandmother at a shopping center in 1991. Baker has
not denied taking part in the attempted robbery, but his lawyers say
there is not enough evidence to show he fired the gun. A co-defendant
was sentenced to life in prison.
In his 71/2 years in office, Glendening has
allowed the executions of two men and commuted the sentence of a third,
two years ago, saying he was not absolutely certain of the man's guilt.
The governor commissioned the death penalty
study two years ago because of concerns that blacks were unfairly being
singled out for death sentences.
The study is being done by Ray Paternoster, a
criminologist at the University of Maryland. He and seven doctoral
students are reviewing about 6,000 criminal cases dating to 1978 where
prosecutors could have sought the death penalty. Maryland reinstated
capital punishment in 1978.
In a study of South Carolina, Paternoster
concluded that a key factor in death sentences there was the race of the
victim.
In Maryland, Paternoster said he hopes to
determine what motivates prosecutors to pursue death sentences and
juries to impose them. He declined to comment on the moratorium.
Illinois
Gov. George Ryan declared the nation's
first moratorium on the death penalty in 2000, citing the release of 13
death row inmates who were found to have been unfairly convicted.
Last month, a commission appointed by Ryan
recommended reforms to reduce the possibility of wrongful convictions,
including cutting the number of crimes eligible for the death penalty
and videotaping police interrogations.
Montgomery
County, Md., prosecutor Doug Gansler,
who rarely presses for a death sentence, predicted the Maryland study
will not find significant racial bias and said the death penalty should
remain the law since life without parole is also an option for
prosecutors.
"Either way, the convicted murderer is
coming out of prison in a box," Gansler said.
|