Editorial
FEBRUARY
19, 2002:
GEORGIA---impending
execution
Executing
Alexander Williams
Alexander
Williams, a chronic paranoid schizophrenic, believes he is under "demon
attack." He thinks Sigourney Weaver is God. He claims insects
removed his left eye and substituted a shell.
Williams is too insane to be executed. So prison
officials in Georgia have been forcing medication on him to make him less
insane and delusional by Wednesday at 7 p.m., when he is scheduled to die
by lethal injection for the 1986 rape and murder of a 16-year-old girl.
Georgia law prohibits executions of the mentally
retarded, but not the mentally ill. And though the U.S. Supreme Court has
said insane individuals should not be executed, it never has directly
addressed the issue of whether such individuals could be forcibly medicated
in order to make them competent enough to be executed.
Yes, that's what's going on in Georgia: Medicating
someone for the sole purpose of making him lucid enough to understand why
he is about to be executed for an act he committed while bordering on
insane. That is bizarre.
The high court has not yet ruled on whether the
imposition of the death penalty on juvenile offenders amounts to a
violation of the 8th Amendment protection against cruel and unusual
punishment, given today's standards of decency. Williams was just 17, still
considered a minor, when he carried out his very adult crime. That made him
too young to vote or drink, but despite his hallucinatory mind, not young
enough to avoid being sentenced to death.
Society regards young people as different from old
people for good reason: they lack the judgment and the impulse control that
adults have. Brain research documents and underscores why we shouldn't hold
juveniles to the same standards of culpability that we do adults.
It doesn't mean Alex Williams should be free to roam
the streets. It means he should be locked away somewhere secure for the
rest of his life.
But that probably won't happen, in large part because
of a third aspect of this case that has been treated inexplicably by the
courts like a piece of irrelevant trivia.
Williams' hideously incompetent trial attorney failed
to bring up Williams' long history of abuse, abandonment and torture at the
hands of his parents. That he frequently was kicked out of the house,
sometimes naked. That his mother beat his toes with a hammer and a
screwdriver, and struck him with various objects. That he regularly would
be denied food and use of the bathroom.
Attorney O.L. Collins didn't bother bringing any of
this up as mitigating evidence at sentencing. Instead he spent a mere 15
minutes instructing the jury to "do what you will" with his
client.
Executing Alexander Williams will amount to nothing
more than an act of hollow, cruel vengeance. The plunger will empty, and
the state of Georgia will have one less problem on its hands--at the cost
of diminishing all of us.
|