PENA
MORTE: USA; ILLINOIS CAMBIA LEGGI, VERSO FINE MORATORIA
NEW
YORK, - Dopo quattro anni di un dibattito politico che ha fatto dell'Illinois un laboratorio sul futuro
della pena di morte negli Usa, la Camera dello Stato ha varato, con un voto di 115-0, un pacchetto di modifiche al sistema della
pena capitale che mira a prevenire gli errori giudiziari.
Il blitz dei parlamentari annulla un veto del governatore Rod
Blagojevich e rende la legge immediatamente esecutiva.
Con l' entrata in vigore delle nuove regole, l'Illinois
sembra avviarsi verso la fine della moratoria alle esecuzioni decisa nel 2000 dall'allora governatore George Ryan, che alla
fine del suo mandato - lo scorso gennaio - svuoto' il braccio della morte annullando le condanne per 167 detenuti. Studi
voluti da Ryan hanno dimostrato che almeno 17 persone sono state condannate a morte ingiustamente da quando l'Illinois ha
reintrodotto la pena capitale.
Sulla base della nuova legge, i giudici potranno tra l'altro
escludere la possibilita' di pena di morte nei casi che si basano in gran parte su un solo testimone o su informatori della
polizia.
La Corte suprema dello Stato ricevera' inoltre il potere di
annullare una condanna che venga ritenuta ''fondamentalmente ingiusta'', anche nel caso non ci siano difetti procedurali o
ragioni tecniche di nullita'. L'esecuzione dei ritardati mentali viene proibita, per adeguare l'Illinois alle direttive della
Corte suprema degli Usa.
The
Daily Northwestern -
Illinois passes death penalty reform package
The Illinois House of Representatives unanimously
passed a package of death penalty reforms Wednesday, but experts and
Northwestern officials said the bill's measures may not go far enough.
The legislation, which follows other recent death
penalty reform measures, passed by a vote of 115-0. The bill will become
effective immediately, as it passed the Senate earlier this month.
Under the bill's provisions, the Illinois Supreme
Court can overturn a death sentence "if the court finds that the death
sentence is fundamentally unjust." The bill also establishes a pilot
program that attempts to create a more impartial line-up procedure and allows
judges to rule out the death penalty in cases where there is only a single
eyewitness account.
"I think that we really have shown the
citizens in Illinois that we are serious about death penalty reform," said
Mary K. O'Brien, D-Coal City, who sponsored of the bill and represents the
House's 75th district, which includes portions of Kankakee and Will counties.
Despite these new provisions, Gov. Rod
Blagojevich said he will not lift the Illinois moratorium on the death penalty
until the effectiveness of the reforms are studied. Former Gov. George Ryan
enacted the moratorium on Jan. 31, 2000.
"You can't just pass a whole series of bills
one day and then the very next day think that you've now solved a pervasive
problem and a broken system," Blagojevich told the Associated Press on
Wednesday.
Sergio Molina, a spokesman for the governor's
office, said Blagojevich has no set time limit to decide the future of the
moratorium.
Blagojevich vetoed a previous version of the bill
in July because a section of it allowed police officers to be suspended if
accused of perjury. But Blagojevich said in a Nov. 5 statement that his concerns
over officers' rights have been addressed in a compromise that restricts who can
accuse police officers of perjury.
Law officials said the bill is a step in the
right direction, but it still does not address all of the problems in the
criminal justice system.
Thomas Sullivan, a former federal prosecutor and
co-chairman of Ryan's Commission on Capital Punishment, said the legislation,
along with previous measures, represents "some very important and much
needed reforms in the Illinois criminal justice system."
But even so, Sullivan said many issues remain
unaddressed, including the number of eligibility factors for a death penalty
sentence and a statewide review commission.
"I think it's a wonderful start,"
Sullivan said, but "there's a ways to go."
Robert Warden, executive director for NU's Center
on Wrongful Convictions, said he was pleased with several of the reforms, but he
worries that many of the provisions could be subverted by police or prosectors.
"This package falls something short of the
Holy Grail," Warden said, "and its effectiveness will depend in large
part on the courts implementing the reforms."
Warden said he would like the reforms to go
further by prohibiting under all circumstances testimony from "snitches"
who often receive reduced sentences in exchange for unreliable information.
"I defy anyone in American history to show
us even one case in which a snitch testimony proved to be accurate," Warden
said.
Edwin Colfax, director of the Illinois Death
Penalty Education Project at the Center on Wrongful Convictions, said the new
bill does not create a uniform death penalty system. Convicted individuals in
rural Illinois area are 5 times more likely to be sentenced to death than those
convicted in Cook County -- a disparity that needs to be addressed, he said.
"There's no question that the bill has a lot
of necessary reforms," he said, but "we can't kid ourselves that the
system has been fixed with these reforms. It doesn't address any problem fully."
O'Brien said the bill that she sponsored will be
reexamined. She helped develop a provision for a committee to evaluate the bill's
effectiveness.
"We wanted to make sure these reforms in
fact are working," she said. "We will have a study and look back after
5 years to determine whether or not these measures are working."
|