WASHINGTON, 07 GEN - Nel carcere di Huntsville
in
Texas e' stata eseguita ieri la prima condanna a morte del 2004
negli Stati Uniti: a ricevere l'iniezione letale e' stato Ynobe
Matthews, un uomo originario di Dallas, condannato per avere
violentato e ucciso una donna nel suo appartamento di College
Station, tre anni e mezzo fa.
Matthews
era stato anche condannato per un altro omicidio, ed era
stato collegato ad altri tre casi di stupro. L'uomo aveva rinunciato
a interporre appello e aveva chiesto di essere messo a
morte.
WASHINGTON, 07 GEN - Nella notte che ha segnato
il
ritorno al lavoro del boia negli Stati Uniti quest'anno, l'Arkansas
ha messo a morte Charles Singleton, un ammalato di
schizofrenia che, secondo i suoi legali, non poteva essere legalmente
sottoposto all'iniezione letale.
Ma
lo Stato dell'Arkansas ha deciso in modo diverso: Singleton,
il cui caso aveva acquistato rilievo nazionale, e' stato
condannato a morte per l'assassinio di un negoziante nel
1979.
Insieme
a Singleton avrebbe dovuto subire l'iniezione letale anche
un altro assassino, che uccise la nipotina di 12 anni. Ma un
giudice federale gli ha riconosciuto, poche ore prima dell'esecuzione,
il diritto a interporre un appello.
Gli
avvocati di Singleton avevano sostenuto che l'uomo non poteva
essere obbligato a curare la sua schizofrenia solo per
essere abbastanza sano da essere messo legalmente a morte: la
legge, infatti, vieta di eseguire la sentenza capitale se il
condannato non capisce perche' viene ucciso.
Ma
una corte dello Stato aveva ordinato che Singleton fosse
curato, cosi' da essere cosciente di quanto stava avvenendo.
E cosi' e' stato.
Dallas
man Texas' 1st execution of 2004
A
Dallas man described by authorities as a serial rapist was executed Tuesday
night for raping and strangling a woman at her College Station apartment 3
1/2 years ago.
Ynobe
Matthews declined to make a final statement before he was put to death, but
mouthed "I love you" several times to a sister and cousin who were
watching him through a window.
As
the drugs began taking effect, he gasped a couple of times, sputtered and
let out a long wheeze before becoming unconscious. 8 minutes later, at 6:18
p.m., he was pronounced dead.
A
half-dozen members of his victims' families watched through another window,
but Matthews ignored them.
Matthews,
27, was condemned for the death of Carolyn Casey, 21, 1 of 2 women he was
convicted of killing. Testimony at his trial also linked him to at least 3
other rapes and 2 other attempted rapes.
Matthews
waived appeals and asked that his execution, the 1st of the year in Texas,
be carried out.
"Plenty
of guys say 'You can beat this,'" he said in a recent death row
interview. "I respect their fight. We all have to choose. ... We all
have whole different paths to take."
Anita
Casey, whose daughter, a day care center teacher, was killed in the 2000
attack, said Matthews was getting what he deserved.
"I
am glad he got caught so he couldn't take another life," she said
before the execution.
Brazos
County District Attorney Bill Turner was surprised that Matthews, a man he
worked to send to death row, was following through on his desire to be
executed.
"He
took that position from the time he got the death penalty," Turner said.
"I believed that would be short-lived."
Evidence
showed that he set fire to Casey's body after strangling her to try to cover
up the crime.
Firefighters
responding to a call from Casey's apartment complex found a small blaze
smoldering around her body. She had been propped up in a seated position
against a bed. Paper, pens and makeup brushes had been set on fire near her.
Matthews,
who grew up in Dallas and dropped out of Lake Highlands High School in the
11th grade, has four children ranging in age from 3 to 10. At the time of
the slaying, he was working as a night stocker at a College Station
supermarket and living with a friend at the same complex where Casey lived.
He and Casey had attended a party at the complex the previous evening.
Matthews'
DNA was found in scrapings taken from under Casey's fingernails and other
forensics evidence tied him to the murder scene.
He
acknowledged being at her apartment but contended the sex was consensual. He
later told detectives there had been a fight, that he strangled Casey and
set fire to her to eliminate evidence and cut a window screen to give the
appearance of a burglary.
"I
spent the whole week getting drunk," he said from death row, adding
that he also had been on a drug binge leading up to the woman's death.
"But that's not an excuse."
DNA
evidence and fingerprints connected Matthews to the 1999 rape and slaying of
Jamie Hart, 21. Her death went unsolved for 14 months after her nude body
was discovered on a rural Brazos County road, 9 miles from where her
abandoned car was left running with the lights on.
Matthews,
whose 1st name is "Ebony" spelled backward, confessed to forcing
his way into her car and raping her. A month after he was condemned for
Casey's slaying, he pleaded guilty to Hart's death.
A
rape victim at his murder trial testified how he "would strangle her
until almost unconscious and then let up. It would happen again and again,"
Turner recalled.
Authorities
found marks of repeated choking on his other victims.
His
execution was the 1st of 4 scheduled this month in Texas, where 24
executions were carried out last year. The total was the highest in the
nation but average for the state over the last decade.
Matthews
becomes the 314th condemned prisoner to be put to death since the state
resumed capital punishment on Dec. 7, 1982. He is the 75th individual put to
death in Texas since Rick Perry became governor in January, 2001.
Matthews
becomes the 886th condemned prisoner to be put to death in the USA since
executions resumed on January 17, 1977.
Arkansas
executes mentally ill inmate - Other man set to die tonight wins stay
Charles
Singleton, a convicted murderer with a history of severe mental illness who
had been on Arkansas' death row longer than any other inmate, was put to death
Tuesday by lethal injection for killing a woman during a robbery.
Witnesses
described Singleton convulsing slightly and coughing after the drugs were
administered.
According
to a statement read by Dinah Tyler, spokeswoman for the Arkansas Department of
Correction, the injection was administered at 8:02 p.m. (9:02 p.m. ET) and
Singleton was pronounced dead at 8:06 p.m. at Cummins Prison, about 70 miles
south of Little Rock.
Singleton's
attorney, Jeffrey Rosenzweig, described himself as "frustrated,
disappointed, saddened" by the execution.
Before
the execution, when asked if he wanted to make a final statement, Singleton,
44, said, "I was going to speak, but I wrote it down. I'll leave it up to
the warden."
Tyler
later read Singleton's written statement, which was a largely rambling missive
peppered with Biblical references.
"As
it is written, I will come forth as you will go," part of the statement
said. "I too am going to take someone's place. You've taught me what you
want done and I will not let you down. God bless, Charles Singleton," the
statement concluded.
Singleton's
last meal, eaten Tuesday evening, was mostly vegetarian, prison officials said.
Singleton had met with family members and his spiritual adviser earlier in the
day.
Meanwhile,
the scheduled execution of another Arkansas inmate Tuesday night was uncertain.
Karl
Roberts, convicted of the 1999 kidnapping, rape and murder of his 12-year-old
niece, filed a motion just hours before the scheduled 9 p.m. (10 p.m. ET)
execution by lethal injection. Roberts has not exhausted the appeals in his
case but has never before made a move to avoid the death penalty.
His
stay was granted Tuesday by the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. State
Attorney General Mike Beebe filed an appeal of the stay, which was rejected.
His office is now considering whether to appeal to the Supreme Court,
spokesman Matt DeCample said.
Roberts'
warrant for execution expires at midnight.
Executed
mentally ill inmate heard voices until end
Charles
Singleton was executed by lethal injection Tuesday night.
The
voices inside Charles Singleton's head varied, in volume and number,
regardless of whether he had taken medication for his schizophrenia. Inside
his Arkansas cell, he said he could often hear voices that speak of killing
him.
Singleton
was executed by lethal injection Tuesday night at the Cummins prison unit in
Varner, about 70 miles south of Little Rock.
Singleton's
attorney said his 44-year-old client welcomed his execution because he was
tired of living with mental illness.
Singleton
understood that he would be put to death and why -- the current legal
standards to qualify for execution, said his attorney, Jeff Rosenzweig.
Singleton,
however, was rational only when he was on medication. It was that fact, as
well as an 18-year-old Supreme Court ruling barring executing the insane, that
his attorney, some members of the legal and medical communities and death
penalty critics pointed to in opposing Singleton's execution.
"If
[Singleton] is artificially made to be competent, then the situation is an
oxymoron," said Ronald Tabak, a New York-based attorney who has
represented clients in death penalty cases.
But
the prosecutor in the Singleton case claimed the defendant was sane at the
time of the crime, and therefore unaffected by the Supreme Court ruling.
"I
do not feel he is being medicated in order to put him to death," said
John Frank Gibson, who hasn't dealt with the Singleton case in recent years.
"He's being medicated to ... keep him healthy, to control him."
Stay
of execution lifted
Singleton
was 19 when he stabbed Mary Lou York to death while robbing a small grocery
store in Hamburg, Arkansas. She identified him before she died. In 1979 he was
convicted and sentenced to death.
A
prison psychiatrist in 1997 diagnosed Singleton as suffering from paranoid
schizophrenia. That same year, a prison medication review panel ordered
Singleton to take antipsychotic drugs after finding he posed a danger to
himself and to others.
After
the medication took effect, Singleton's psychotic symptoms abated and Arkansas
made plans to execute him.
Singleton's
attorneys filed a lawsuit arguing the state could not constitutionally restore
his client's mental competency through the use of forced medication and then
execute him.
In
October 2001, a panel of the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that
Singleton be sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
The
state appealed, and last February a sharply divided full 8th Circuit Court
lifted a stay of execution for Singleton.
The
court said at the time that because Singleton was voluntarily taking his
medication and because Arkansas had an interest in having sane inmates, the
side effect of sanity should not affect Singleton's sentence.
In
October, the Supreme Court declined without comment to hear the Singleton
case.
Most
Americans have consistently supported the death penalty since it was
reinstated in the 1970s. But polls show that the issue of mental illness
sharply affects public opinion.
The
son of the victim in the Singleton case says the insanity question is just a
ploy.
"I
don't believe it," Charles York said. "It's just something they use
to prolong things to keep it in the court system."
Singleton
becomes the 1st condemned inmate to be put to death this year in Arkansas and
the 26th overall since the state resumed capital punishment in 1990.
Singleton
becomes the 2nd condemned inmate to be put to death this year in the USA and
the 887th overall since America resumed executions on January 17, 1977.
|