Ohio
Murderer, Struggling to the End, Is Executed
CINCINNATI
- A 45-year-old condemned man, struggling and yelling "please God, help
me," had to be carried into the execution chamber by six guards before
being put to death on Wednesday for the 1983 murder of an elderly woman,
prison officials said.
Lewis
Williams, Jr., was given a lethal injection at 10:15 a.m. EST at the prison in
Lucasville, Ohio, for killing Leoma Chmielewski, 76.
"Please
God, help me. God, please help. Please hear my cry," Williams shouted as
he was strapped onto a gurney to receive the lethal injection, prison
spokeswoman Andrea Dean said.
His
mother, Bonnie Williams, witnessed her son's struggle and was taken out in a
wheelchair afterward.
Throughout
his two decades on death row, Williams claimed innocence, arguing prosecutors
used trumped-up evidence and coerced witnesses, including testimony from two
inmates who testified he confessed while in jail awaiting trial.
Witnesses
testified Williams was at Chmielewski's home the night she was shot, and
police found gunshot residue on his clothing and his shoe print on the hem of
her dress. A trail of coins and the woman's empty pay envelopes were found
nearby.
Williams
had lived across the street from Chmielewski, who was known in her Cleveland
neighborhood for holding several jobs to help support family members.
Williams
claimed he had left the victim's house before she was killed.
In
his appeals, Williams argued his defense attorneys were inept because they
presented little evidence to persuade the jury that he deserved mercy because
he had been abused and became a cocaine user by age 13.
His
scheduled June 2002 execution was stayed by a judge to evaluate whether
Williams was retarded, which would have commuted his death sentence. Experts
hired by his attorneys determined he was not retarded and Williams fired his
lawyers.
The
U.S. Supreme Court turned down his final appeal arguing execution by lethal
injection amounted to cruel and unusual punishment and was therefore
unconstitutional.
Several
death row inmates have lodged appeals based on disputed evidence that the
lethal cocktail of drugs immobilizes the condemned but does not spare
suffering. A federal appeals court recently stayed the execution of a Virginia
inmate on those grounds.
Williams
was the ninth person executed in Ohio since 1999, when the state resumed
executions after a 36-year hiatus. He was the fifth person to be executed this
year in the United States, and the 890th since the nation resumed the death
penalty in 1976.
For
his final meal, Williams chose the prison's regular dinner of smoked sausage,
rice, black-eyed peas, collard greens and vanilla pudding.
OHIO:
Williams Execution Timeline
Lewis Williams, executed
Wednesday for the 1983 fatal robbery of a Cleveland woman, struggled and
pleaded for help from the moment the execution process began. He was the 1st
inmate to struggle since Ohio resumed executions in 1999.
A timeline:
-- 9:51 a.m. Movement
detected around the preparation table in a room next to the death chamber, as
seen through two video monitors. It is the 1st time in 9 executions that the
preparation process was viewed by witnesses.
-- 9:52 a.m. Members of
the 12-person execution team forcibly lift Williams from his knees and pry his
hand off the edge of the preparation table. Williams' mother, Bonnie Williams,
66, of Columbus, sobs as she watches from a witness room. There were no
witnesses for the victim, Leoma Chmielewski.
-- 9:54 a.m. At least
nine members of the team work to restrain a struggling Williams with a series
of straps. Williams, yelling and shaking his head, repeatedly strains to lift
himself up.
-- 9:56 a.m. Williams
continues to struggle and shout. One guard standing by his head alternately
restrains him and pats his right shoulder to comfort him.
-- 10:02 a.m. The shunts
are successfully placed on the inside of Williams' forearms above the elbow.
Williams has stopped shouting but continues to speak, often in a type of chant,
that is not audible.
-- 10:03 a.m. The straps
are taken off and Williams, his body drooping, is carried into the execution
chamber by four guards. He yells, "I'm not guilty, I'm not guilty, God,
please help me," as 7 guards strap him down.
-- 10:06 a.m. A member of
the execution team enters the chamber and attaches the tubes carrying the
lethal chemicals to the shunts in Williams' arms.
-- 10:07 a.m. Williams is
asked for a last statement. "God, please help me, God, please hear my cry,"
he said. James Haviland, warden of the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility in
Lucasville, gives a signal not visible to witnesses to start the flow of
chemicals.
-- 10:08 a.m. After
continuing to cry out and yell, Williams abruptly stops speaking as the
chemicals apparently take effect. The sobbing of his mother grows much louder.
-- 10:14 a.m. Haviland
orders the curtains drawn between the chamber and the witness room.
-- 10:15 a.m. Haviland
reopens the curtains and declares the time of death as 10:15 a.m.
|